Spillway Dirt vs Fill Dirt vs Topsoil
Fill dirt is any dirt used to build height. Spillway dirt is one kind of fill dirt: a fine silt with some clay, the fill we sell in New Orleans. Topsoil is the top layer that grass and plants grow in. Use fill to raise and shape the ground, then cap it with a few inches of topsoil, our Premium Garden Soil, wherever something has to grow.
If you remember one thing, make it this: fill builds height, topsoil (Premium Garden Soil) grows grass. Most yard problems in Greater New Orleans need both, in that order.
Key Takeaways
- "Fill dirt" is a job, not one material. Spillway Dirt is the fill dirt we sell: silt with some clay, low in organic matter, and it packs down when compacted in layers.
- Topsoil is for growing. Our topsoil answer is Premium Garden Soil, a screened blend of topsoil and compost.
- Raise a low yard with Spillway Dirt first, then a few inches of Premium Garden Soil on top before sod or seed.
- Much of the New Orleans area sits on soft river sediment that slowly sinks, so low spots often come back. Fill in thin, compacted layers and slope the grade away from the house.
- Fill doesn't fix water that has nowhere to go. A yard that never drains needs a drainage plan first.
What Is Fill Dirt?
Fill dirt is whatever dirt you use to fill a hole, raise a low area or build up ground. It's chosen for what it does under your feet, not for what grows in it. Good fill packs down firm when you spread it in thin layers and compact each one, and it doesn't rot or settle the way soil full of roots and compost does.
Because "fill dirt" describes the job, two loads both sold as fill can be very different materials.
What Is Spillway Dirt?
Spillway Dirt is the fill dirt we sell. It's a silt fill: fine-grained silt with some clay in it, low in organic matter. Spread it in thin layers and compact each one, and it packs down.
That makes it the dirt for filling holes and washouts, raising a low lot or yard, and building up ground under a driveway or pad before the base stone goes on. It's also what you use to reshape a yard so rain runs away from the house.
It is not screened, so expect a small root, stick or bit of debris now and then. That's fine under sod, under base stone or under more soil, but it isn't a finished surface and it isn't planting soil.
What Is Topsoil?
Topsoil is the upper layer of soil, the part roots live in. It's looser and richer than fill, and it's meant to stay that way: you don't compact it into a hard layer.
Our topsoil answer is Premium Garden Soil, a screened blend of topsoil and compost. It's for filling new raised beds, building or topping up flower and shrub beds, backfill when planting trees and shrubs, and a top layer of a few inches over fill before sod or seed.
It is not the material for raising ground in bulk. Compost settles as it breaks down, so a deep layer of planting soil sinks. Fill is the material made for volume.
Spillway Dirt, Fill Dirt and Premium Garden Soil at a Glance
| Spillway Dirt | Fill dirt (general) | Premium Garden Soil | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Silt with some clay, low in organic matter | Any dirt used to build height | A screened blend of topsoil and compost |
| Main job | Fill, raise and grade ground | Fill and raise ground | Grow grass and plants |
| Compact it? | Yes, in thin layers | Yes, in thin layers | No, keep it loose |
| Where it goes | Underneath | Underneath | On top, a few inches |
| Screened? | No | Varies | Yes |
Why New Orleans Yards Need the Right Dirt
The ground is soft and it sinks. New Orleans was built on river sediment, and the land settles over time. Surveys of the leveed parts of the metro area from 1951 to 1995 measured an average of about 5 millimeters of subsidence a year (USGS, 2003). Over the life of a house, that adds up, which is why a low spot you filled years ago can show up again. Building it back with fill that packs down firm, in thin layers, holds better than dumping a soft soil and hoping.
Many yards are low and flat. Water needs a slope to leave. The finished grade should fall at least 4 percent away from the house (Illinois Extension, 2020). On a flat lot that small slope is easy to lose, so check it with a level and a straight board, not by eye.
Heavy, slow ground holds water. Silt and clay soils take water in slowly, so a low spot puddles after a summer storm. Raising and reshaping the grade moves where rain goes. But if the water has no outlet at all, fill only moves the puddle. That's a job for a French drain or another drainage plan first; see French drain gravel for the stone that goes in one.
Which One Do You Need?
A low spot or a low yard: Spillway Dirt for the height, compacted in layers about 1 to 2 inches at a time with a hand tamper or 4 to 6 inches with a plate compactor (Illinois Extension, 2020). Then a few inches of Premium Garden Soil on top where grass will grow. Our guide on how much fill dirt to raise a low yard does the math.
A new flower bed or raised bed: Premium Garden Soil, mixed into the existing soil for an in-ground bed.
A pad for a shed or a driveway: Spillway Dirt can bring the grade up underneath. The firm layer on top is Crushed Concrete, compacted. For fill under a house slab or a footing, follow your engineer's spec.
Leveling around a pool deck or bedding a pipe: River Sand is the sand fill for those jobs.
A wet yard: fix where the water goes first, then fill.
Not sure? The What material do I need? tool asks about your project and your ground and lists the layers from the bottom up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is spillway dirt the same as fill dirt?
Spillway Dirt is a kind of fill dirt. "Fill dirt" means any dirt used to build height; Spillway Dirt is a specific silt fill with some clay, low in organic matter, that packs down when compacted in layers.
Can I plant grass directly in spillway dirt?
Not well. It's a fill, low in organic matter, and it isn't screened. Cap it with a few inches of Premium Garden Soil, which is what grass roots into.
Is fill dirt or topsoil better for a low spot in my yard?
Fill for the height, topsoil (our Premium Garden Soil) for the last few inches. Raising a low spot with planting soil alone wastes it, because compost settles and the spot sinks again.
Why does my New Orleans yard keep sinking?
The area sits on soft river sediment that settles over time, and surveys have measured the land sinking by millimeters a year. Fill that packs firm, spread in thin layers, holds better than a soft soil, but expect to touch up low spots now and then.
Does topsoil help drainage?
It helps rain soak in where things grow, but it doesn't drain a yard that has nowhere for water to go. Slope the grade away from the house, and for standing water plan a drain first.
See Your Price for Your Address
Pick the dirt for your job and see what it costs delivered to your street. Enter your address. If it's in our delivery area, you'll see the real price for Spillway Dirt and Premium Garden Soil before you pay. Just outside it, you'll see: "You're just outside our standard area for this material. We'll price it by hand and reply within 2 business hours."
Get your delivered price for your address
Materials for this job
Sources
Related guides
- Sand for Sandbags in New Orleans: River Sand Delivered
- How Much Sand Do I Need? Beds, Pipes and Pool Bases
- Water Standing in Your Yard After Rain? New Orleans Fixes
Delivered by city
Spillway Dirt
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Avondale, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Destrehan, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Edgard, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Garyville, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Gramercy, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Gretna, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Harahan, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Harvey, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Jefferson, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Kenner, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Metairie, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in New Orleans, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Reserve, LA
- Spillway Dirt Delivery in Violet, LA